The Mary Magdalene Debate

The Mary Magdalene Debate:

And so the discussion in my mind continues. Is the figure to Christ’s right in Michelangelo’s work, Mary Magdalene or John as London’s National Gallery and the Louvre claim?

An absolute gem of a place is the Museum of Sacred Art,  Funchal, Madeira.

There’s not an awful amount that can be said about this island but it’s rich cultural heritage in the form of its own and in particular the art that was imported from Flanders in the 16th Century is outstanding.

Of specialnote is the work to quote: ‘Attributed to the Master of the Holy Blood’ Flanders, Bruges (1515-1520).

The central panel of this Descent from the Cross replicates a lost original by Rogier van der Weyden, from the 1440s’.

The figure in the panel to the right has been identifed as Mary Magdalene. There Mary is with her trademark red dress and the ‘sacred ‘V’ ‘ parting her hair.

Furthermore in the Funchal museum is a work by the Flemish artist Jan Provoost of Mary Magdalene dated 1524-1526. A red dress, red hair, the hair parting ‘V’. Sumptuous upper clothing illustrating her wealthy background.

All the icons as we’ve seen with Michelangelo’s work.

In this museum is a fantastic awesome set of wooden sculptures by a 16th Century Maderian carpenter, used in processions on feast days etc.

Look closely at the central figures in this Last Supper scene. Jesus Christ as central, to his right St Paul with the tonsure and to his left St John.

That is the traditional interpretation, albeit Paul and John are also depicted on respective alternative sides to Jesus.

But is that John? Surely it’s a female with full reddened lips, slight eyebrows, and a womanly countenance. Furthermore, the hair ‘V’ parting is there and the dress is red. With her head affectionatetly on Christ’s shoulder, could this be Mary Magdalene? And Christ’s wife?

The Mary Magdalene Debate